The Eurasia Project on Population too Family History represents an innovative too of import genre of comparative historical research. L...
The Eurasia Project on Population too Family History represents an innovative too of import genre of comparative historical research. Lead scholars inward this projection include James Lee, Cameron Campbell, Tommy Bengtsson, Norika Tsuya, Satomi Kurosu, too George Alter, every bit good every bit many others. The showtime 2 volumes of enquiry from the project, Life nether Pressure: Mortality too Living Standards inward Europe too Asia, 1700-1900 and Prudence too Pressure: Reproduction too Human Agency inward Europe too Asia, 1700-1900, appeared inward 2005 too 2010, too the most recent book Similarity inward Difference: Marriage inward Europe too Asia, 1700-1900 is almost to appear. The showtime book addresses variations inward mortality, the instant addresses fertility, too the most recent addresses nuptiality. Taken together, the iii volumes render an encompassing handling of the principal parameters of demographic behavior. (Also of involvement is Living Standards inward the Past: New Perspectives on Well-Being inward Asia too Europe (2005), which provides a rigorous analysis of what is known almost existent reward too living standards across many locations inward Europe too Asia.)
The EAP projection is an approach to historical demography that is intended to render a substantially to a greater extent than detailed agreement of the historical trajectory of demography inward dissimilar parts of the Eurasian dry reason mass—population size, nuptiality, fertility, mortality, etc., every bit good every bit a to a greater extent than empirically constrained gear upwards of hypotheses almost the causes of changes inward these factors over time. This enquiry represents an of import illustration of collaborative “large science” inward the historical social sciences, inward that it involves enquiry teams at a number of centers inward Europe, Asia, too the U.S. who convey agreed on a gear upwards of standards on the reason of which to stand upwards for too analyze the demographic information they convey collected. In the aggregate, the report makes exercise of 2.5 ane thou one thousand longitudinally linked private records inward over a dozen locations across Eurasia. Research teams are focusing on detailed demographic records inward community-sized locations across Eurasia, including Sweden, Belgium, Italy, Japan, too China, too these researchers aim to render analysis of their findings that is sufficiently structured every bit to permit rigorous comparing across cases.
The researchers depict the projection inward these terms: "New information too novel methods … convey begun to illuminate the complexities of demographic responses to exogenous stress, economical too otherwise.… Combined time-series too event-history analyses of longitudinal, nominative, microlevel information forthwith let for the finely grained differentiation of mortality, fertility, too other demographic responses past times social class, household context, too other dimensions at the private level” (Bengtsson et al., 2004, pp. viii-ix). Their goals are ambitious -- to render detailed, analytically sophisticated multi-generational studies of a number of populations across Eurasia. The studies are intended to permit the researchers to probe issues of causation every bit good every bit to position of import dimensions of similarity too difference across regions too communities.
A fundamental to this approach is to convey assembled comparable micro-level longitudinal demographic information inward dissimilar geographic locations across Europe too Asia. The enquiry groups convey attempted to larn inward at a micro-picture of the individual-level demographic events with individual, relationship, too household characteristics; to seat together a timeline of “stress”; too to run into how outcomes for people’s demographic events comport inward human relationship to the patterns of alter inward environmental too economical characteristics. This allows them to probe the ways inward which varying social too economical institutions—family structure, economical niche structure, dry reason nutrient subsidy practices—influence people inward dissimilar places.
The projection has likewise made of import innovations inward the statistical methods that tin last used inside historical demography. Alter (1988), Lee too Campbell (1997), too others convey led the means inward creating methods based on event-history analysis for allowing statistical analysis of demographic events at the individual-community level, too this is an of import conception relative to the techniques used to flora large population parameters of demographical behavior. George Alter's exercise of these methods is described inward a prior post.
An of import historiographic characteristic of this travel is the determination the researchers convey made almost the scale of groups to last studied. The travel is non intended to tell the demographic story of the nations inward which the communities nether report exist, but rather to render detailed snapshots of local populations over extended periods of time. Lee, Campbell, too Bengtsson write, “Our focus on comparing of communities, non countries, represents a novel approach inward social scientific discipline history. While nosotros generalize almost for certain aspects of human behavior, nosotros do then inside the cultural, economic, too historical contexts of specific communities, non at the national level” (Bengtsson et al., 2004, p. 7).
This enquiry is distinguished past times several of import features. First, it attempts to combine aggregate too private levels, edifice aggregate conclusions from analysis of individual-level data. Second, it is deeply comparative, inward that these groups deliberately essay out to position similarities too differences at both extremes of Eurasia too inside Europe too Asia. Third, this enquiry projection examines the “large-scale processes too implications of the fertility too mortality transitions,” too to do then inward a means that permits comparing across regions. Finally, the enquiry attempts to evaluate the large hypotheses (especially Malthusianism) concerning differences inward demographic regimes betwixt Europe too Asia. So the Eurasia Project on Population too Family History is both micro too macro, with a coherent method for joining the 2 levels; it is comparative; too it is intended to render a reason for discovering causal relationships alongside factors that influence demographic outcomes.
The Eurasia Project approach tends to downplay the “large” mutual institutions at the national bird too to emphasize instead the local institutions that require contact too constrain individuals. These researchers likewise emphasize the score of variability that exists across societies too local settings with regard to demographic behavior. Some of the local too regional social too cultural regimes that the authors position too explore every bit causal variables inward explaining outcomes include position unit of measurement structure, world provisioning systems for nutrient emergency, wealth too class, too dry reason tenure.
Another of import implication of this enquiry pertains to the viability of the Malthusian hypothesis almost macro-demography. The authors discovery that their results refute the Malthusian conclusions too generalizations almost positive too preventive checks too Europe versus Asia. They discovery that position unit of measurement practices, demographic institutions, too economical settings vary sufficiently across the map of Eurasia every bit to brand it impossible to larn inward at grand differentiating statements almost European too Asian demography (or English linguistic communication too Chinese demography). In particular, they discovery that the bear witness shows that Chinese demographic deportment resulted inward fertility rates that were broadly comparable to those of Western Europe.
There are withal but about of import generalizations to last made almost Europe too almost Asia with regard to demographic patterns; but in that location are likewise cross-cutting similarities inward but about regions of Europe with but about regions of Asia, too in that location are of import differences across both Europe too Asia. This finding illustrates a highly of import mutual thread that emerges from comparative economical history inward many areas—that regions comprise substantial variation inside their boundaries, too that these variations may sometimes last every bit meaning every bit those across regions.
This trunk of enquiry represents a pivotal contribution to the means that nosotros recall almost the past times too pursue its history. The contributors demo the highly complex too various patterns of the criterion of living too demographic deportment inward the pre-industrial period. The full general moving painting emerging from these studies is non ane of a peachy deviation betwixt East too West during early on modern times, but instead ane of considerable similarities. These similarities non alone pertain to economical aspects of criterion of living but likewise to demography too the sensitivity of population deportment to economical fluctuations. Perhaps in ane trial too for all nosotros tin seat Malthus out of the centre phase when nosotros recall almost historical population behavior!
Percent of single males past times historic current . Source: Similarity inward Difference, chapter 3
COMMENTS